BOISE -- A federal judge says three Idaho men convicted of hate crimes for beating a black man outside a Nampa Wal-Mart will serve prison time.
U.S. District Judge Edward Lodge sentenced 23-year-old Michael Bullard to more than four years in prison, 24-year-old Richard Armstrong to more than 3 years in prison and 23-year-old James Whitewater to a year and a half in prison.
Bullard and Armstrong were convicted of committing a hate crime in July. Whitewater pleaded guilty to conspiracy to violate rights before the case went to trial.
Prosecutors said the three plotted an attack against Raylen Smith, then 24, after encountering him in the aisles of Wal-Mart on the Fourth of July, 2008. The trio beat him in the parking lot until he blacked out.
Comments have been turned off for this article.