BOISE - Secretary of State Lawerence Denney says he will not hand over detailed voter information to President Donald Trump's commission on election fraud as part of a settlement with the Idaho Democratic Party.
Idaho Democratic officials sued Denney earlier this month arguing that the commission's probe is illegal because Idaho law bans releasing private information for commercial use.
The commission had originally given all 50 states until July 14 to hand over key points of voter data including dates of birth and the last four digits of each voter's Social Security numbers. However, the commission has since backed off from that request after facing multiple legal challenges.
Denney said Tuesday he has agreed to not comply with the original request sent by Trump's voter panel. Furthermore, Denney will give the state Democratic Party a 10-day notice if he considers complying with any future requests from the commission.
UDPATE: Idaho Secretary of State Lawerence Denney responded on Thursday to this article, which originated from the Associated Press. Here is his response, in full:
There are times when it is not worth fighting to correct being misquoted or straighten out a misperception. There are certain times, however, when for the benefit of others, the battle for transparency must be fought. In light of recent media coverage surrounding a letter from The Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity, I feel strongly that right now is one of those times.
A July 19 article penned by the Associated Press led with the headline stating “Idaho won't comply with Trump voter panel request”. While technically accurate, it is far from the complete story. The article goes further to say that “Idaho now joins 17 other states and the District of Columbia also refusing to comply with the commission's request.” The reality is that Idaho has not refused to comply, but rather, with the suspension of the request by the Designated Federal Officer for the commission, no “refusal” was necessary.
When I was asked recently by a reporter to confirm if we were sending anything in response to the Commission’s request, my answer was “No” The better answer would have been, “No - not to this request, at this time, in the manner in which it has been presented, and since the request is suspended.”
Regarding the lawsuit, the AP article quoted Democratic Party Chair Bert Marley’s statement, "We are very pleased to tell Idahoans that we have protected their privacy by negotiating for an agreement that Secretary Denney will not send the voter information sought by the Trump Commission.” Chairman Marley - you negotiated for no such thing, and you did nothing to protect the privacy of Idahoans. That privacy was already well protected, and I take significant offense to the fact that you would insinuate otherwise. What you did do, however, was file an absolutely unfounded and frivolous lawsuit, (that you eventually dismissed) playing and preying upon public fear, and compounding the problem through misinformation. I will not allow that to continue.
The AP article led with the line “Secretary of State Lawerence Denney announced Tuesday he will not hand over detailed voter information to President Donald Trump's commission on election fraud as part of a settlement with the Idaho Democratic Party.” I made no such announcement, and the decision to not send any information was made outside the context of the Democratic Party’s dismissal of the suit, not because of it.
As such, I will be providing a comprehensive timeline of the events and details surrounding this issue on the Secretary of State website to bring further clarity. Citizens of Idaho – when it comes to your private information and your election decisions, know that both I and my staff are working diligently and daily to preserve and protect your rights. Know also that we are subject to the laws of Idaho as they are written, and those laws include the Idaho Public Records Act. Thank you for the opportunity to serve you, and to present the truth on this matter.
Idaho Secretary of State